Book Categories
|
World War II Infantry Tactics (2): Company and Battalion (Elite) |
Buy World War II Infantry Tactics (2): Company and Battalion (Elite) here, one of 1792 World War Two books offered for sale at discount prices here in the history books section at R bookshop. There are currently 85978 history books in our history books section, and over 1,000,000 books listed in our book store. We greatly appreciate your patronage at R bookshop and look forward to offering you a large selection of great books at discount prices now and in the future. Thank you for shopping at R Bookshop!
|
You Are Here: Home > History Books > World War Two > Item 157
|
World War II Infantry Tactics (2): Company and Battalion (Elite)
|
by Stephen Bull and Peter Dennis
Sales Rank: 211874
|
List Price: $17.95
$14.00
At Amazon
on 10-19-2008.
|
|
|
|
Features
Cover Type: Paperback with 64 pages
Published by: Osprey Publishing February 5, 2005
Written in: English
ISBN 10 Number: 1841766631
ISBN 13 Number: 978-1841766638
Book Dimensions:
9.8 x 7.3 x 0.4 inches
Weighs: 7 ounces
Product Description
World War II is often seen as a confrontation of technology – tanks and aircraft, artillery and engineering. But at the heart of the battlefield was the struggle between infantrymen, and the technology was there to enable them to capture ground or hold it. This second of two books on the organization and tactics of the German, US and British infantry in Europe focuses on national differences in the development of company and battalion tactics – including those of motorized units – and the confrontation and co-operation between infantry and tanks. Contemporary photographs and diagrams and vivid colour plates illustrate what tactical theories actually meant on the ground at human scale.
Publisher Description
An unrivalled illustrated reference source on fighting men and commanders, past and present. Each volume is packed with full colour artwork, making military history uniquely accessible to enthusiasts of all ages.
Reader Reviews
This review is from: World War II Infantry Tactics (1): Squad and Platoon (Elite) (Paperback)
Dr. Stephen Bull, a British museum curator and author of two volumes on WW1 trench warfare in Osprey's Elite series, attempts to outline the essence of Second World War infantry tactics in two new volumes in the Elite series. In the first volume, Dr. Bull addresses squad and platoon tactics of the US, Britain and Germany. Although this volume is graphically attractive and appears comprehensive, it essentially drives by the subject at a high rate of speed, accepting questionable popular theories and failing to draw appropriate conclusions. Indeed, while Dr. Bull's grasp of weaponry appears sound, his grasp of small unit tactics seems superficial and fixated on "sexy" topics like snipers and hand-to-hand combat. Dr. Bull draws his material from three sources: official training manuals from the period, veterans accounts and secondary works. In the first section, Dr. Bull addresses the soldier's experience (casualty rates, combat fatigue, physical demands); this section really isn't necessary for discussing tactics but appears influenced by John Keegan's Face of Battle methodology. At any rate, Dr Bull uses a variety of anecdotal evidence from different British and American infantry units to suggest that infantry losses in 1944-1945 were as heavy or worse than that experienced in 1916-1918. Dr. Bull misses the point - it is not the quantity of loss as much as the quality of losses that really matters. As three D-Day veterans told me, "our leadership bled away rapidly in combat." Replacing ten privates who took three months to train is fairly easy, but replacing one combat-experienced NCO or junior officer is much tougher. At any rate, while it is clear that "the poor bloody infantry" always suffers the most, it is not clear how this section adds to a discussion of tactics. It would have been more appropriate to discuss the training of squad and platoon leaders - and how this differed between the three armies - than to discuss individual soldier issues better left to the Warrior series. The next section on Training has some useful material on camouflage, physical training, individual movement techniques (IMT), and battle drills, but also includes garbage on hand-to-hand combat "techniques," including kicking, eye-gouging and "anti-hair pulling tactics." Basics are ignored: how much marksmanship training did the average WW2 infantryman get before battle? What was medical care like? I bet the average British or US platoon was better fed than the average German platoon in 1944-1945. The author also ignores other important (but mundane) issues such as noise/light/litter discipline, mission preparation, rehearsals and tactical adaptability. The section on "The Squad Ethos" parrots the near-axiomatic notion that soldiers only fight for their buddies and ignores the fact that officers and NCOs have other motives. If officers sought to protect their men, they could not order attacks that risked heavy losses. Officers are, in fact, usually motivated by some kind of higher purpose (ideology, careerism, etc). The section on squad organization and weapons details the US, German and British squads, although there is little effort to distinguish between "leg," mechanized and airborne squads. Nor does Dr. Bull ever mention that squads are mere tactical building blocks - they normally do not conduct independent operations. The whole idea of "squad tactics" is a bit artificial, since even squad-size patrols or ambushes are usually part of a larger unit operation. The heart is this volume is the seven pages on squad offensive and defensive tactics, and it focuses almost exclusively on the hasty variants. I was amazed that Dr. Bull hardly mentions patrolling or ambush tactics - the bread and butter of small unit infantry operations. Deliberate assaults, with external fire support or engineers, are ignored and there is virtually no mention of tank-infantry cooperation. Somehow, in his ellipitical way in approaching this subject, Dr. Bull obscures the fundamental essence of offensive tactics, which is find 'em, fix 'em, flank 'em, f--- 'em. Bull is also a little flippant with terminology, comparing an assault to "temporary insanity" - a proper assault requires a very rationale thought processes, not a bunch of out-of-control impulses. Bull quotes one apparently trigger-happy veteran who talked about the "excitement of constantly stuffing fresh ammunition into the magazines and blazing away" - not a good example. I think Dr. Bull has confused infantry tactics with Telly Savalas' character in "The Dirty Dozen." As for defensive tactics, Dr. Bull suggests that advance posts could be "within about 2,000 yards of a main position" which is nonsense - well beyond range of organic weapons and how could they communicate? LP/OPs should be within range of one's own weapons - about 300-500 meters at the squad level. The section on the Platoon almost appears to be an afterthought and it is only 23% of the volume, and half of that focuses on snipers. Key questions, like how support weapons should be used or squads employed (the two up one back standard) get remarkably little attention. Several of the color plates are also a bit suspect. The plate depicting a US rifle platoon in the defense shows a position with no forward security (LP/OP) and located on the crest of a small hill (not the "military crest"), which means the men would be skylined and highly vulnerable. Both the platoon leader and platoon sergeant are depicted at a considerable distance from the machinegun team, but experience showed that the platoon leader would locate himself close to this vital weapon. The plate on the German defensive position in Normandy is also a bit deceptive, since it suggests that the Germans typically burrowed holes through hedgerows for all their riflemen. I visited the remnants of a German company-size position near St. Lo in Normandy in June 1989 and was surprised at the relative crudity of the position. Even after 45 years, it was obvious that the Germans had cut simple holes through the TOP of the hedgerows.
Back To Top
|
World War II Infantry Tactics (2): Company and Battalion (Elite)
Available from Amazon
Price: $14.00
Updated on 10-19-2008.
|
NOTICE: All prices, availability, and specifications
are subject to verification by their respective retailers.
| We offer World War II Infantry Tactics (2): Company and Battalion (Elite) and other related World War Two Books here at Rbookshop.com. To view more books about World War Two please use the previous and next buttons near the top of this page.
|
|
|
Search for books at
