Languages of Belonging: Islam, Regional Identity, and the Making of Kashmir

Features

• Cover Type: Hard Cover with 320 pages
• Published by: Oxford University Press, USA June 3, 2004
• Written in: English
• ISBN 10 Number: 0195219392
• ISBN 13 Number: 978-0195219395
• Book Dimensions: 8.9 x 5.5 x 1.4 inches
• Weighs: 1.4 pounds

Product Review

"This is an outstanding book. Based on massive archival research in Delhi, Jammu and Srinagar and the unearthing of rare Kashmiri literary sources, it skillfully uncovers the religious sensibilities that underlay the formation of Kashmir's regional identity in the late-nineteenth and early-twentieth century Languages of Belonging will light up new ways of understanding the formation of identities in South Asia's regions." --Sugata Bose, Harvard University
"Zutshi looks at the development of Kashmir's intellectual, economic, cultural, and religious history over the "long duree" to illustrate the shifting nature of Kashmiri identity(ies) in the last two hundred years.The book is significant in its interweaving of heretofore untapped sources, especially Kashmiri poetry, to describe the development of Kashmiri political consciousness. Recommended"--CHOICE
"Zutshi arrives at [her] conclusions withattention to nuance and detail[Zutshi's] study of the working of Dogra rule suggests the need for a careful examination of what, if any, meaning the notion of a 'Hindu state' may have actually had to contemporariesNotions of a homogenous Kashmirir Muslim identity, Zutshi's analysis suggests, need to be tempered by an understanding of the working of caste, class, and ideology."--American Historical Review
"nuance[d] and detail[ed]."--American Historical Review
"Languages of Belonging is a quantum leap forward in Kashmir studies and will make one of the best histories of 'regional' identities and economies in India yet produced. The work brings forward a great deal of new and important material and provides for a new framework for understanding regional identities in South Asia."--C.A. Bayly, Cambridge University
"Rarely has Kasimir received sustained scholarly attention that goes beyond the issues of rival territorial claims and policy studies. Drawing on a rich vein of sources, this book breaks new groundA monograph of exceptional rigour and insight, a must for specialist and lay human being alike." --Mahesh Rangarajan, Visiting Assistant Professor at Cornell University


Product Description
Despite its centrality to the political life of India and Pakistan, Kashmir has met with rather perfunctory treatment from historians of South Asia. The few works of history and politics that have appeared on this region, moreover, insist on defining Kashmiri culture, history, and identity in terms of the ahistorical concept of Kashmiriyat, or a uniquely Kashmiri cultural identity. This book, in contrast, questions the notion of any transcendent cultural uniqueness and Kashmiriyat by returning Kashmir to the mainstream of South Asian historiography. It looks at the hundred-year impact of indirect colonial rule on Kashmirs class formation. It studies the uses (and abuses) made of Kashmirs political elites by the state. It looks at the responses of Kashmirs society to social and economic restructuring. It shows that while all these historical changes had a profound impact on the political culture of the Kashmir Valley, there is nothing very inevitable or quite definite about the 'political regionalism' and 'Islamic particularism' of this area. Using local language sources and every important archive, this major history of the formation of Kashmir shows precisely how the Kashmir Valley assumed the position it has come to occupy in postcolonial South Asia.

Reader Reviews
To understand the `making of Kashmir', it is important to discover the spirit and soul of this land with a history going back thousands of years.A scholar concerned with only a fragment of this long history must still take a holistic perspective in order to identify the unique character of the land.This book is a scholarly study of a relatively recent period in the history of Kashmir(1846-1953),the period of Dogra rule An overall perspective has not been provided and the reader has no opportunity to understand even the bare essentials of Hindu,Buddhist , Islamic and Sikh periods . Zutshi has glossed over or ignored evidence supporting the rich tradition of tolerance and mutual respect between Hindus and Muslims which survived several periods of persecution of the Kashmir Pandit minority.Based partly on unreliable sources and partly on flawed interpretation, Zutshi has made sweeping ,unresearched statements about the post-1953 period which is,in any case, outside the scope of the project.Consequently,a strong bias in favour of minority separatists permeates the book. [...] Comment | | (Report this)